|
This
indepth analysis of cataract and cataract surgery was written by Simon
G. Levy MD MRCP FRCS FRCOphth, Consultant Ophthalmologist for a lecture
given to optometrists (opticians). It provides a detailed analysis of
the history of cataract surgery, pre-operative workup, surgical technique
and post-operative management of cataract.
UNDERSTANDING
CATARACT: A GUIDE FOR THE PERPLEXED
(Slide show and
notes)
SIMON G LEVY
MD MRCP FRCS FRCOphth
| Modern cataract
surgery transforms lives …. and it transforms more lives than any
other surgery |
INDEX
Types and causes
of cataract
Symptoms
Lens anatomy
History of cataract surgery
Phacoemulsification/small incision surgery
The cataract surgeons job
Maximising unaided distance acuity
Pre operative biometry
Managing astigmatism
Maximising unaided near acuity
Calculated astigmatism for good near acuity
Multifocal IOLs
Minimising psychological distress
Minimising recovery time
When to have surgery
Refractive outcomes
Risk
Comorbidity
Anaesthesia for cataract surgery
Cataract in children
Post op cataract medication
Secondary Cataract
Lensectomy for high ametropes and Phakic IOLs
The optometrists role
|
Types
and Causes
- nuclear
sclerosis (brown)
- posterior
subcapsular
- bubbles
- spikes
- crystalline
- sutural,
etc. etc.
|
Nuclear sclerosis
is the commonest type of cataract and usually age related.
Posterior subcapsular
cataract is found in younger patients. It is sometimes due to oral/topical/?
inhaled steroids. So medical conditions such as asthma for which oral
steroid has been prescribed can have a profound indirect effect on vision.
Generally speaking
most cataracts are age related. Everyone gets them eventually!
Unusual types e.g.
crystalline, sutural maybe genetic but this is rare.
All types of cataract
occur earlier in high myopes.
Trauma, uveitis,
steroid use and diabetes can all cause cataract.
The role of UV light
'ageing' the lens is unclear, but it may be important.
|
Symptoms
of cataract
- blurred
vision
- glare
- muted colour
sense
- index myopia
- monocular
diplopia
|
The extent to which
a patient is symptomatic from cataract depends on many factors. Obviously
the younger the patient, the more likely they are to be aware of visual
loss. Converseley elderly patients with modest visual requirements are
often remarkably unaware of their cataract. The speed of onset of the
cataract also plays a part. Classically nuclear sclerosis comes on slowly
so the patient has plenty of time to get used to the change it has caused,
and may not notice it all. Drivers have early symptoms because of glare
from oncoming headlights. Some types of cataract cause symptoms quicker
than others. Classically this applies to posterior subcapsular catataracts
which are frequently right in the centre of the lens. These cataracts
scatter light so causing glare very early. Also on a bright day when the
pupil closes down a patient may suddenly have count fingers vision when
he may still be 6/6 in dim illumination. The presence of comorbidity,
for example macular degeneration, also affects a patients ability to perceive
the extent to which cataract has reduced vision.
LENS ANATOMY
|
Lens
Anatomy
- Anterior
capsule
- nucleus
- posterior
capsule
|
All the clinician/optometrist
needs to know for practical purposes about lens anatomy is that the lens
substance is wrapped up in an elastic capsule. The capsule is immensely
important from the surgeons point of view because (1) the anterior capsule
has to be removed very carefully during cataract surgery (2) the integrity
of the posterior capsule must be protected at all costs during cataract
surgery.
You will all be aware
of the zonular/ciliary body apparatus and its role in accommodation. Accommodation
is largely academic in the context of cataract since most patients are
already presbyopic. However see the discussion on 'pseudo-accommodation'
in the section on maximising unaided near acuity.
HISTORY OF CATARACT SURGERY
|
Cataract
Surgery History
- Antiquity
- 900 Couching
- 1900 -
1970 Intracapsular surgery (ICCE)
- 1948 - First
Intraocular lens (IOL)
- 1980 -
1990 Extracapsular surgery
|
Couching was the
practice of making a crude cut in the eye and then inserting an object
such as a finger, stick or spoon-handle into the eye and pushing the lens
to the bottom of the eye. A technique to be used only in extremis obviously!
Perhaps better than blindness in advanced cataract although presumably
quite capable of causing blindness in itself. So long as the lens capsule
was not ruptured, so releasing lens matter, there was surprisingly little
intraocular inflammation and perhaps some positive benefit to the patient
might result.
Intracapsular surgery
was the first type of modern cataract surgery. In this technique a wide
surgical incision is made at the limbus and a surgical instrument used
to grip the lens and remove it in toto from the eye. A major step forward
from couching but still quite traumatic especially since in the early
days there were no sutures suitable for closing the incision. The wound
was therefore left open and the patient had to be kept in bed for up to
a fortnight with his head sandwiched between pillows to stop him moving
until the wound healed.
Until the advent
of the mass availability of contact lenses (1960s onwards) ICCE surgery
was inevitably aphakic. Patients wore +12 glasses which were optically
highly unsatisfactory causing magnification, distortion and peripheral
scotomas. Anisometropia was such a problem that uniocular cataract surgery
was contra indicated. The early types of contact lenses were not much
help because most elderly patients found them too inconvenient to handle.
The advent of soft contact lenses made an enormous difference to ICCE
cataract surgery but constant supervision was required if they were to
be worn on an extended wear basis and complications such as corneal infections
were not infrequent.
Sir Harold Ridley
invented the first intraocular lens in 1948, the operation being performed
at St Thomas Hospital London. This was one of the most important discoveries
of modern medicine, ranking with antibiotics, vaccines, anaesthetics,
viagra, etc. in its capacity to improve the quality of human life. However
partly because of the relatively crude nature of the early designs and
party because of a rather conservative attitude amongst ophthalmologists,
IOLs were not widely adopted until the 1980s.
Extracapsular (ECCE)
surgery arrived in the 1980s. This was a big step forward over ICCE because,
after the same rather gross corneal incision, the lens was removed in
such a way that the posterior capsule was left intact. This was much less
destructive to the eye with improved outcomes as a result. Also by this
time most cataract surgery was performed with the benefit of an IOL.
Phacoemulsification
(small incision cataract surgery) was discovered in the mid 1960s by the
brilliant American ophthalmologist Dr Charles Kelman. This extraordinary
man revolutionised cataract surgery by inventing phacoemulsification.
Just as with Sir Harold Ridley's invention of the IOL, phacoemulsification
was only slowly introduced partly because the initial phaco machines were
technically crude so that the surgery was exceptionally difficult and
partly because of suspicion amongst the ophthalmic community. However
from the 1990s onwards phaco became the treatment of choice for cataract
and in my opinion extracapsular surgery is now utterly outmoded.
PHACOEMULSIFICATION - HOW
IT'S DONE
|
Phacoemulsification
- how it's done
- Small (3mm)
main incision
- Tiny (0.75mm)
side incision
- Lens capsule
removed
- Ultrasound
phaco probe liquefies and aspirates lens
- Replacement
IOL inserted
- Incision
self-seals no stitches
|
Phacoemulsification
surgery time depends on factors such as surgical skill, the quality of
the available equipment and factors relating to the patient such as the
type of cataract. An average figure is 20-30 minutes. This does not include
the time spent in the operating theatre preparing the patient before surgery
and preparing the patient for return to the ward post-operatively. Altogether
patients should expect 50-60 minutes in the operating theatre.
|
Phacoemulsification
- Why it's so good
Small incision -
- Less induced
astigmatism
- Much safer
|
Less astigmatism:
the phaco incision is 3mm or less whilst the ECCE incision was 10-12mm.
Induced astigmatism is proportional to the incision length². Generally
an unsutured phaco incision causes 0-0.5 dioptre flattening when made
on the temporal side of the eye. The same 3mm incision made superiorally
i.e. at the 12o'clock position causes 0.5-0.75 dioptres of flattening.
Incisions made in the sclera cause less flattening than those made in
the cornea.
Much safer: the small
phaco incision is completely filled by the phaco probe. Because of this
and the sophisticated fluidics of the modern phaco machines, virtually
all intraocular events during surgery are under the control of the surgeon.
The result is therefore down to the surgeons skill. In the days of ECCE
surgery, the huge incision made in the eye created completely unstable
intraocular dynamics over which the surgeon only had limited control.
This was one of the reasons why ECCE surgery is much more dangerous than
phaco with events such as vitreous loss and cornea damage much more common.
Quicker recovery:
The small phaco incision is gentle to the eye. No stitches are required
which might cause induced astigmatism and require removal at a later date.
The incision heals quickly so that glasses can be prescribed soon after
surgery.
|
The
Cataract Surgeons Job
- Don't damage
the eye!
- Maximise
unaided distance acuity
- Maximise
unaided near acuity
- Minimise
psychological distress
|
|
Maximising
Unaided Distance Acuity
- Optimise
biometry
- Astigmatism
reduction
|
Biometry is the process
of measuring the eye prior to cataract surgery to select the correct strength
of intraocular lens to insert during surgery. See below for more details.
|
Biometry
Great surgical technique useless if biometry not correct
IOLs are like shoes - excruciating if don't fit and remember - you
can't take them out after surgery!
|
|
IOL
power proportional axial length and cornea power
(curvature)
Every eye is different
Axial length - ultrasound
Cornea power - keratometry
IOL power varies -5 to +30 dioptres
|
Biometry is such
an important aspect of cataract surgery that numerous complete text books
have been written about it.
Axial length is measured
with an A-scan ultrasound machine. This is not 'automatic' and requires
great skill and judgement to use properly. An error of 0.4mm in the axial
length will cause 1 dioptre of ametropia.
Keratometry is very
important. A 1 dioptre error in the Ks equates to 1 dioptre ametropia
post op. Ks can be difficult to measure accurately e.g. greasy tear films,
cornea scars, pterygium, trachoma, keratoconus and poor fixation. Contact
lenses must be out before Ks are taken. Soft lenses - 1 week. Gas permeable
lenses - 2 weeks. PMMA lenses - 3 weeks.
Axial length and
Ks are fed into a computer loaded with one of several biometry formulae.
The best is 'SRK(T)' which is an acronym for its authors.
The biometry formulae
become inaccurate if the eye is 'diseased' e.g. cornea scars or previous
refractive surgery. Refractive surgery patients e.g. LASIK will require
new formulae which are currently under development. Alternatively some
educated guess work is needed.
RANGES OF IOL POWER
'Normal' eyes +21
to +24 dioptres
Myopes may be as low as -5 dioptres.
Hyperopes may be as high as +40 dioptres. Because IOLs are only made up
to +30 dioptres power it may be necessary to insert 2 ('piggy backing')
into the eye.
TYPES OF IOL
All are made from
plastic (not glass!). Newer models are flexible e.g. silicone so that
they can be folded in half and inserted through the 3mm phaco incision.
They unfold to a diameter of 5-6mm.
MANAGING ASTIGMATISM
|
Remember!
Cataract
surgery is done on the lens and cornea
|
|
Astigmatism
-
The
good, the bad and the very ugly
|
|
Astigmatism
Bad
and horribly ugly -
Astigmatism reduces near and distance unaided acuity
|
|
Astigmatism
Surprisingly
good -
A small amount of cyl in the correct axis increases unaided near
acuity
|
Note - see below
for more information on calculated astigmatism in cataract surgery to
increase near vision.
|
Reducing
Post-op Astigmatism
- Small incision
- No sutures
- Place incision
on steep meridian
- Astigmatic
keratotomy
- Toric IOLs
|
The cornea is the
eye's main focusing organ. It's shape is critical for the eye's refractive
power. Any change in cornea shape caused e.g. by an incision, sutures,
scar, etc. may cause astigmatism.
Remember that astigmatism
may be pre-existing or induced by surgery. Phacoemulsification provides
an opportunity to reduce pre-existing astigmatism as well as surgically
induced astigmatism.
Small incision: Phaco
incision is 3mm wide, ECCE incision 10-12mm wide. Induced astigmatism
is proportional to incision length ². Phaco is obviously therefore
much better.
No sutures: no sutures
are (usually) used after phaco whilst ECCE required 5 to 7. Sutures distort/tighten
the incision and cause unpredictable astigmatism.
Place incision on
steep meridian: any surgical incision made in the cornea weakens the cornea
causing flattening. Flattening reduces the corneas focusing power. The
amount of flattening is proportional to the incision depth, length and
closeness to the corneal apex. These parameters can all be manipulated
by the surgeon. The surgeon will place the incision on the steepest meridian
of cornea power (at 90% to the axis of the astigmatism on refraction!).
Astigmatic keratotomy:
these are additional incisions, usually paired, placed on the steep meridian
of astigmatism. These cause flattening of the steep meridian.
Toric IOLs. IOLs
which incorporate a correction for astigmatism. A nice idea but expensive
and difficult to use because even a slight misalignment between the axis
of the IOL and the axis of the astigmatism will cause an unpredictable
refractive outcome.
|
Maximising
Unaided Near Acuity
- Accurate
biometry
- Astigmatism
reduction
- Other stratagems
|
|
Near
Acuity - 'Other Stratagems'
- Calculated
myopia
- Monovision
- Calculated
astigmatism
- Multifocal
IOLs
- Small pupils
- Pseudo-accommodation
|
Calculated myopia:
useful for patients who have always been 2 - 4 dioptres myopic and who
prefer good unaided near vision and don't mind wearing distance glasses.
Monovision: after
cataract surgery monovision is permanent! The patient must be familiar
with it beforehand and able to cope with anisometropia of about 2.5 dioptres
i.e. quite a lot. Given that the post-op refraction can never be guaranteed
to be exactly what is planned, the patient could end up with more anisometropia
than 2.5 dioptres. Generally this option is not favoured by cataract surgeons.
Calculated astigmatism:
see 'Calculated Astigmatism and Near Acuity' below.
Multifocal IOLs:
see information on this subject below.
Small pupils: pupil
diameter is always smaller in older patients. This has a pin hole effect
of increasing the depth of field and is probably the major reason for
some patients having much better unaided near acuity than would be expected
given their refraction.
Pseudo-accommodation:
amazing but true! As shown by ultrasound studies. Ciliary muscle contraction
occurs post-op causing anterior movement of the IOL and therefore 'pseudo-accommodation'
of up to 1 dioptre in some patients. There is no way of predicting which
patients will enjoy this extraordinary effect.
CALCULATED ASTIGMATISM AND
NEAR ACUITY
|
Calculated
Astigmatism and Near Acuity
0.5 - 0.75 dioptres of simple myopic astigmatism @ 90º or 180º
improves near acuity a lot without reducing distance acuity much
|
One focal plane will
be on the retina for distance vision and the other will be in front of
the retina i.e. useful for near vision. 0.75 dioptres may not seem enough
to enable the patient to read, but remember they have small pupils and
sometimes pseudo-accommodation.
Software packages
(such as Mr Paul Chell's 'kill the cyl' or Mr Julian Steven's 'Vector
Inspector' packages) enable the surgeon to manipulate the location, depth
and length of the main incision and the same parameters for astigmatic
keratotomy in order to leave a calculated amount/axis of astigmatism post-operatively.
MULTIFOCAL IOLS
|
The
Allergan ARRAY multifocal IOL
HOW IT WORKS
- Aspheric
refractive design
- 5 concentric
zones each with full range of refractive power: far ? +2.80 Add
- Zones 1,3
& 5 are far dominant, zones 2 & 4 are near dominant
- Far-middle-near
in simultaneous focus
- Light distribution:
far 50%, middle 13%, near 37%
|
|
OTHER
MULTIFOCAL IOLs
- Difractive
multifocals
- Refractive
bifocals
- Not in
widespread current use
|
|
The
Allergan ARRAY multifocal IOL
- suitable patients
-
- Not too
visually demanding, esp. older patients
- No more
than 1D astigmatism post-op
- Pupil size
normal
- No intra-operative
complication
- Not highly
myopic or hyperopic
|
|
MULTIFOCAL
IOLs -
TROUBLESHOOTING
- Visually
demanding, young patients
- Small pupils
(<2mm)
- >1.0D
post-operative astigmatism
- IOL decentration,
tilt or out of capsular bag
- Bilateral
implantation best
- Phacoemulsification
essential
Consultant
Ophthalmologist
|
|
MULTIFOCAL
IOLs - GLARE
- High %
patients
- Not usually
severe
- Usually
temporary
- Reduced
by -
- Bilateral
implantation
- Good
phaco technique
- Overplusing
slightly
- Glare is
common in cataract
- Glare is
common in monofocal IOLs
|
|
The
Allergan ARRAY multifocal IOL
HOW TO REFRACT POST-OP
- Autorefraction
invalid
- Use central
pupil for retinoscopy
- Give max.
plus for distance correction to overcome pseudo-accommodation
- Give normal
near add if necessary
|
MAXIMISING PSYCHOLOGICAL DISTRESS
OR: HOW TO MAKE FRIENDS WITH YOUR PATIENT
|
MINIMISING
PSYCHOLOGICAL DISTRESS
- Pre-op
counselling
- Information
literature/website
- Relatives
in operating theatre
- Talk to
patient during op'n ('vocal local')
- Topical
('no needle') anaesthesia
|
This is an extremely
important aspect of cataract surgery and sadly one that is all too often
partially or completely neglected. Cataract surgery can be a relatively
happy and painless experience, psychologically speaking, if the patients
feelings are borne in mind. If not it can be something of a nightmare
for the patient and his/her family. Basically the ophthalmologist should
possess enough imagination/sympathy to empathise with the patient and
treat the patient accordingly. Frequently and sadly ophthalmologists believe
that only the 'technical' aspects of the job such as avoiding surgical
complication, getting the post-op refraction right etc. matter.
INFORMATION. The
main problem is often simply that patients have no knowledge of what is
involved in cataract surgery and are terrified of the unknown. I provide
information on cataract surgery, what to do beforehand, what to expect
afterwards, etc. both in printed form and via my website. Whilst not all
patients will want to read this information, in my experience the majority
do.
PRE-CONCEPTIONS.
I try to get some idea during the pre-operative consultation of whether
there is something on the patients mind that they find particularly bothersome
about their forthcoming surgery. For example there is sometimes something
terrible in the patients family history such as a cataract operation that
went badly wrong. Discussing this will often enable me to put the patients
mind at rest - for example pointing out that cataract surgery is now much
safer than it used to be.
TALKING TO OTHER
PATIENTS . Occasionally it is helpful to put a patient in touch with someone
who has already had cataract surgery. However most patients already know
someone to whom they can talk.
TALK TO THE PATIENTS
BEFORE THEIR SURGERY. This is very important. I make an absolute rule
of chatting to the patients for a few minutes just before to their surgery
and 'walking them through' what will happen. I give a brief overview of
what to expect, in particular pointing out things like the cataract machine
making a hissing noise, water from the cataract machine trickling down
their ear during the operation (no, its not blood) and the fact that the
eye will not have good vision for sometime after the surgery (no, nothing
has gone wrong, this is normal).
RELATIVES IN THE
OPERATING THEATRE. Generally speaking I have no objection to a relative
holding the patients hand in the operating theatre. This is very reassuring,
especially if the patient does not speak English.
'VOCAL LOCAL'. I
talk to the patient during the surgery. Most patients find this very reassuring.
The sort of thing I say to the patient includes (1) what are the noises
they can hear (2) what stage is the operation at e.g. 'I am just finishing
the stage of removing the cataract' or 'I am just about to insert the
replacement lens' (3) how much longer the operation will last. (4) 'everything
is going well'. The Americans coined the phrase 'vocal local' (anaesthesia).
TOPICAL ANAESTHESIA.
The best way, in my opinion, of doing most cataract surgery is to use
powerful anaesthetic eye drops rather than an anaesthetic injection. This
is comfortable for the patient and the eyes look better after surgery.
Psychologically, patients are often hugely reassured to be told that 'no
needle' will be used for their local anaesthetic.
DE-BRIEFING PATIENTS.
A brief chat half an hour or so after the operation to tell the patient
that all went well serves as 'closure' for a stressful event.
VISION RECOVERY TIME.
It is extremely important to remember to warn patients that the eye will
not regain vision until 12 to 24 hours after the operation. They will
be reassured to know that this does not indicate that there has been a
complication.
MINIMISING RECOVERY TIME
|
Minimising
Recovery Time
- Phaco much
faster recovery than ECCE
- Good vision
after 12-24 hours
- Glasses
at 1 month
|
Remember - time is
precious in elderly patients!
Generally vision
returns within 12-24 hours after phaco. A substantial proportion of post-operative
recuperation has already occurred by one day although healing will continue
for a month or sometimes longer. Glasses are prescribed after 2-4 weeks.
Phaco recovery faster
than ECCE because of the small incision.
(1) gentle to the eye - less cutting = less healing after
(2) Much less astigmatism
(3) No sutures to remove
(4) Less chance of a complication than with ECCE
Recovery after local
anaesthesia much quicker than general anaesthesia.
See 'Minimising Psychological
Distress' above for other tips.
WHEN TO HAVE SURGERY
|
When
to have surgery
As soon as
vision less than patient requires
|
The risk of phaco
is sufficiently small (see discussion on risk below) that early (even
very early) surgery is now appropriate. Local anaesthesia is very safe
for the patients general health especially if topical anaesthesia is used.
Therefore the age and health of the patient are usually irrelevant. Again
this supports a policy of early surgery.
Surgery is appropriate
as soon as the cataract becomes troublesome to the patient. Do not wait
until the cataract is advanced ('ripe'). It is best to let the patient
decide when to have surgery. However remember that elderly patients are
often unaware of slowly progressive nuclear sclerosis even when the process
has become advanced. It is appropriate for the surgeon/optometrist to
encourage the patient to undergo surgery in this circumstance even if
the patient is reluctant.
Remember that time
is precious in elderly patients. The sooner the surgery is done the longer
they will have to enjoy the visual improvement.
Another factor supporting early surgery is that the risk of surgery increases
sharply if nuclear sclerotic-type cataracts are allowed to advance. The
lens becomes very hard making the surgery technically much more difficult.
Symptoms justifying
surgery include -
- Reduced vision.
Remember that Snellen visual acuity is often remarkably well preserved
in nuclear sclerosis, despite severe loss of contrast sensitivity, the
latter being a much better measure of visual performance. Also a posterior
subcapsular cataract patient may have normal vision and no symptoms
in dim illumination but count fingers vision and severe glare on a bright
day when the pupil shuts down. This is because early nuclear sclerosis
often occupies only the central portion of the lens.
- Troublesome 'index'
(cataract - induced) myopia or other refractive change.
- Blunting of colour
perception.
- Glare when driving
or on a sunny day.
- Anisometropia.
- Monocular diplopia.
- The legal requirement
for driving is relatively rigorous, equating to about 6/10 aided in
at least one eye
REFRACTIVE OUTCOMES
|
Refractive
Outcomes
90% eyes in
range +0.5 to - 1.0DS
|
|
Refractive
Outcomes
- Strive
for good unaided vision
- Phaco better
than ECCE
- Biometry
crucial
|
Generally refractive
outcomes after phaco are excellent. My impression is that optometrists
share this opinion especially if they have been in practice long enough
to have refracted many patients who have undergone ECCE surgery.
Good biometry is
crucial to a good refractive outcome as it determines the power of the
IOL inserted and so the spherical refraction post-op. Phaco permits pre
existing astigmatism to be reduced during the operation (see 'Reducing
Post-op Astigmatism' above) and induces very little astigmatism.
RISK
|
Poor
Refractive Outcome
- Unusual
- Rx
- glasses
- contact
lenses
- change
IOL
|
|
COMPLICATIONS
- Phaco is
generally 'safe'
- Never trivialise
cataract surgery
- Many intra/post
op complications can occur
|
Phaco is much safer
than ECCE because the surgeon controls the operation rather than vice
the versa. See 'Phacoemulsification - Why It's So Good' above for a discussion
on why this is so.
Complications are
usually avoidable by a good surgeon (but not always! See below).
Intra-operative complications
include -
- Corneal oedema
- Iris damage
- Vitreous loss
following posterior capsule tear
- Dropped lens
- Expulsive haemmorage.
- Inability to insert
an IOL
Post-operative complications
include -
- A scratchy/red
eye
- Cystoid macular
oedema (CMO)
- Poor refractive
outcome
- Leaking incision
- Prolonged uveitis
- Endophthalmitis
- Retina detachment
- A scratchy/red
eye is the commonest post-operative problem. It is a nuisance but will
disappear after one day - 2/3 months. Causes are discomfort from the
incision, post-operative uveitis, recurrent cornea erosion syndrome
from corneal epithelial trauma during surgery and post-op eye drop allergy.
Sometimes unrelated problems such as blepharitis are 'brought to the
patients attention' by the operation. Treatment is reassurance (vocal
local!); topical anaesthetics; topical steroids; Acular (a non-steroidal
analgesic/anti inflammatory agent); topical lubricants; occasionally
a bandage contact lens.
- CMO is probably
the commonest severe post-operative complication. It comes on after
about a week post-op. Vision drops from 6/6 to 6/36 or so. It is more
common if a complication has occurred during surgery such as vitreous
loss. Diabetics may have CMO as a component of diabetic retinopathy
but they are also more prone to get it as a result of cataract surgery.
CMO may occur after completely uncomplicated surgery. It usually disappears
when treated with a combination of G. Acular and G. Maxidex QID for
a month.
How frequent are
complications?
The National Cataract
Survey 1998 carried out by the Royal College of Ophthalmologists of 18,500
cases identified a 7.5% of intraocular complications!!! This is a very
high figure, hence my comment on the slide that the risks associated with
cataract surgery should never be trivialised. However I must say that
most experienced phaco surgeons find these figures surprisingly high.
I find that the risks of a significant intra-operative complication with
most eyes is about 1:200. The risk of a serious post-operative complication
(mostly CMO) is about 1:100.
The risk of phaco
is reduced by:
- Surgical skill
and experience.
- The quality of
surgical equipment and nursing support available
The risk of surgery
is increased by many factors including:
- Short (hyperopic)
eyes, less than 20mm axial length
- Long (myopic)
eyes, greater than 28mm axial length
- Opaque corneas
- Hard (long standing)
cataract
- Deep set eyes
- Pupils that don't
dilate
- Very elderly patients
(older than 90-something who will have fragile ocular tissues)
- Pseudoexfoliative
glaucoma in which there is a tendency for the lens to come adrift during
surgery and sink to the bottom of the eye.
COMORBIDITY
|
Comorbidity
- e.g. Glaucoma,
AMD
- VA won't
be perfect
- Patient
must be told
- 'always'
worth doing
|
The standard approach
is to offer phaco to optimise ocular performance unless the retina/optic
nerve are completely unfunctional. The patient must be told not to expect
an unrealistic outcome. Peripheral vision in AMD is better than none.
|
Anaesthesia
for Cataracts
- GA
- LA - injection
- LA - topical
- Biometry
crucial
|
General anaesthesia
used to be ubiquitous but is now hardly ever used because it is unpleasant
for the patient, dangerous for those in poor health and expensive for
the health service. It is usually unnecessary. I still use it in patients
who (1) insist (2) are claustrophobic (3) have an uncontrollable head
or body tremor (4) are demented (5) are mentally subnormal (6) children.
Patients (perhaps
surprisingly) generally have no difficulty keeping their head and body
still during cataract surgery under local anaesthesia. There is virtually
no risk to the patients general health from the LA, the patients feel
much better after if they have not had a GA and they can go home immediately
after surgery so that overnight stays are a thing of the past.
Local anaesthetics
used to be given by injection. This often hurts, the prospect frightens
the patient and the injection is in my opinion not 'good for' the eye.
I now almost always use topical anaesthesia. Several potent anaesthetic
eye drops (Amethocine) are administered and additional intracameral anaesthetic
is given via the main incision. This technique is usually painless and
the patients appreciate the 'no needle' approach. To the surgeon the eyes
feel better whilst the surgery is done and they certainly look better
afterwards since injecting local anaesthesia sometimes causes ferocious
conjunctival haemorrhage. Post-operative recovery is quicker after topical
anaesthesia since the eye is not 'asleep' to the same extent and disconcerting
post-op diplopia never occurs as it often does with injection local anaesthesia.
More surgical skill is required since the eye can rove around during the
operation although usually it doesn't because (1) the patient is asked
to look at the light from the operating microscope and this keeps the
eye still (2) because the surgical instruments inside the eye control
the eye's movements.
Poor refractive outcome
after phaco is unusual. The best way of avoiding it is for the surgeon
to practice 'refractive cataract surgery' and to be aware of all the potential
pitfalls and so avoid them.
As always good pre-operative
biometry is essential.
There are two types
of poor outcome -
- Subjective - an
unhappy patient but a reasonable refractive outcome. The main cause
is an unrealistic expectation of the outcome e.g. total glasses independence.
The management is avoidance - it is essential to educate the patient
before surgery as to what can be reasonably expected.
- Objective - a
genuinely poor refractive outcome. There are many types e.g. (1) high
sphere especially if it is hyperopic (any residual hyperopia is a poor
outcome). (2) high cyl especially if it is so high that glasses are
no good. (3) anisometropia.
The causes of a poor
refractive outcome include (1) pre-operative biometry done badly (2) pre-operative
biometry done well but in difficult circumstances such as pre-existing
cornea scars. (3) High pre-existing cyl which is difficult to reduce surgically
during the operation (4) induced astigmatism caused by outdated ECCE techniques
- THIS USED TO BE THE COMMONEST CAUSE OF POOR REFRACTIVE OUTCOME BEFORE
PHACO. (5) inserting the wrong IOL during surgery (6) manufacturer mis-labelling
IOL so that the wrong power is implanted into the eye (7) unusual pre-operative
circumstances. For example unilateral cataract in a high myope. Should
the surgeon make the patient emmetropic in the operated eye so causing
anisometropia or render the operated eye as myopic as previously so missing
the chance to cure the patients myopia?
The treatment of
an unsatisfactory refractive outcome includes -
- Avoidance
- Encourage the
patient to use glasses if practical
- Contact lenses
are ok but frankly often a nuisance in elderly patients. This is especially
true if the new silicone soft extended wear contact lenses are inappropriate
for example because of high astigmatism.
- Explant the
IOL from the eye and replace it. This is a high risk surgical strategy.
- Implant an additional
IOL to correct spherical error
- Do astigmatic
keratotomy to treat residual astigmatism.
- LASIK is generally
safe and effective. LASIK should be done at least two months after
the initial surgery so that the phaco incision doesn't split when
the LASIK flap is made.
CATARACT IN CHILDREN
Paediatric
Cataract
- Rare
- Various
causes
- Surgery
similar to adult
- Amblyopia
= main problem
|
Care of children
with cataract is best undertaken by specialist paediatric cataract surgeons
e.g. those at Great Ormond Street Hospital. The surgery is similar to
that done in an adult including the nowadays routine implantation of IOLs.
The surgery can be 'tricky'. It is always done under GA. One of the difficulties
is judging the correct IOL power to implant. This is because the eye will
obviously grow as the child gets older. It is best to deliberately induce
hyperopia so that as the eye gets larger it gradually becomes more emmetropic.
The main problem
with paediatric cataract surgery is amblyopia because of anisometropia
and ametropia, especially in unilateral cataract. Constant patching may
be necessary.
A 6/6 outcome is
perfectly possible but the child will inevitably be 'presbyopic'.
POST OPERATIVE CATARACT MEDICATION
|
Cataract
Post-Op
- Steroid/antibiotic
eye drop QID 2 weeks BD 2 weeks
- Eye shield
at night 1 week
- Glasses
1 month
|
|
Secondary
Cataract
Not another
cataract!
- Posterior
capsule opacification
- > 3
months after surgery
- 50% patients
- Laser capsulotomy
easy
|
Secondary cataract
is very common, some estimates being as high as 50% of all cases. It is
more frequent in children and young adults. It is also more frequent when
the primary pathology is posterior subcapsular cataract.
It is a relatively
trivial problem in the developed world. Treatment is Nd:YAG laser capsulotomy.
This is quick, painless, simple and almost completely safe. Occasional
complications are retinal detachment, cystoid macular oedema and severe
elevation of IOP. However these are extremely uncommon.
The laser vaporises/cuts
the thickened posterior capsule restoring vision to its post-operative
level almost immediately.
Secondary cataract
is a huge problem in the developing world where resources for laser capsulotomy
are not available.
|
Lensectomy
- Phaco on
clear lens
- Highly effective
- Generally
'safe'
- Treatment
of choice for older high myopes/hyperopes
|
Lensectomy has become
established as the treatment of choice for high myopes/hyperopes who are
(1) presbyopic (2) beyond the reach of LASIK i.e. more than about 4 dioptres
hyperopic or 9 dioptres myopic.
These patients are
(1) often highly motivated (2) tend to get cataract sooner than in normal
eyes. Patients need to be told about (1) the surgical risk (probably no
greater than for LASIK and (2) presbyopia post-op.
|
Phakic
IOL
IOL implanted.
Natural lens left in situ
Highly effective
Treatment of
choice for young high myopes/hyperopes
|
An IOL is implanted
into the eye. The natural lens is left in situ. Various models are available
eg the 'Artisan'/'Implantable Contact Lens'.
I use the Artisan
which clips onto the iris. It will correct any degree of myopia. For example
I have rendered patients who were almost 20 dioptres myopic emmetropic
using this technique. It is the treatment of choice for pre-presbyopic
myopes beyond the range of LASIK (more than 9 dioptres or so). These patients
are often highly motivated.
Accommodation is
preserved using this technique which is why it is appropriate for younger
patients. The IOL can be removed if necessary i.e. the procedure is reversible/adjustable.
Great surgical skill
is necessary to avoid damage to the lens and cornea. The patients must
be made aware of the risk associated with this procedure especially being
told not to rub/put pressure on the eye which might force the cornea into
contact with the IOL. The possibility of long term damage to the cornea
endothelium is a reason why this technique is not generally advised for
high hyperopes who have very small eyes.
|
The
Optometrists' Role
- Much greater
abroad
- Action
on Cataract !
|
Abroad, especially
in North America, optometrists are involved in many aspects of cataract
management other than providing glasses afterwards. This includes diagnosis
of cataract, direct referral to ophthalmologists, pre-operative counselling
and post-operative care such as prescribing/discontinuing medication.
The recent government
consultation paper 'Action on Cataract' suggested much greater optometric
input into cataract in the UK for example direct referral.
I would welcome these
changes and I imagine many optometrists would too.
Optometrists are
well able to judge how good a cataract surgeon's outcomes are!
|